Cloud computing is a model for enabling convenient, ondemand network access to a shared pool of configurable computing resources e. Tax implications of cloud computing how real taxes fit into. Cloud computing is distinguished from the purchase of downloaded or otherwise electronically delivered software, which is taxable as the sale of tangible personal property unless the business use exemption is applicable to the purchase. Cloud computing 28 november 2012 vered kirshner, tax partner, pwc israel omri yaniv, international tax partner, pwc israel. The texas director of tax administration issued a ruling in response to a companys questions concerning cloud computing services and texas sales and use tax. Yesterdays law, todays technology by carolynn iafrate kranz and iris kitamura i. Cloud computing is a versatile technology that can support a broadspectrum of applications.
Introduction everyone is talking about cloud computing, but no one knows how to tax it. Cloud computing is in itself not new technology, but a. Part 4 cloudy with a chance of sales tax an overview of state tax schemes being applied to cloud based transactions. And for technology companies, this means that cloud tax issues and impacts are plentiful, complex and significant. Cloud computing was coined for what happens when applications and services are moved into the internet cloud. A closer look at sales and use taxation of the cloud. Cloud computing is an arrangement to access and use hardware and software hosted on the server of a vendor for a fee. Meanwhile, technology continues to evolve, forcing tax administrators to determine how these new products and services should be taxed. The low cost of cloud computing and its dynamic scaling renders it an innovation driver for small. This struggle is most evident in the area of sales and use tax where there is no uniformity among states on how to tax or even characterize these transactions. Many states use a primary function test to discover the purpose of the transaction and decide taxability on 1cara griffith, will paas get a pass from state sales tax. In indonesia there is no specific tax regulation stipulating the tax treatment of cyber businesses including cloud computing. Software that is only hosted is not taxable as prewritten software. Facts according to your letter, the terms, cloud computing and digital content refer to a variety of software products and services that use a server infrastructure and are accessed and used by end users using computer devices.
License fees for remotely accessed prewritten software are taxable if the purchased software is used in utah. Tax treatment for cloud computing needs scrutiny, says law firm it may be difficult to arrive at any concrete conclusion on the appropriate tax treatment of new business models like cloud computing involving multiple and intricately connected features or transactions, says a note on cloud computing issued by law firm nishith desai associates. Cloud computing addresses many of the efficiencies contractors seek, including mobile accessibility, scalability, and more expansive information technology it capabilities without massive outlays and larger longterm fixed costs. Michigan clarifies policy on taxability of cloud computing. Holderness although tax practitioners have seen quite a few articles published in the tax press regarding the state and local tax effects of cloud computing especially sales and use tax concerns, there has been a. It also examines the excise and customs tax implications on cloud computing transactions in india but concentrates mostly around sales. Cloud computing with software the division stated that saas, paas, and iaas do not. Cloud services help companies turn it resources into a flexible, elastic, and selfservice set of resources that they can more easily manage. Reflections on the colorado decision, state tax notes, july 16, 2012, p. This whitepaper covers the different types of cloud computing service models, their taxability, and how lacking specific legislation many state taxing authorities increasingly rely on letter rulings, administrative notices and audits to shape policy on the sales and use tax treatment of cloud computing services all with varying results. Conclusion accessing taxable canned software is taxable when the user is located in pennsylvania. Cloud computing taxation and digital content sales issues. Tax implications of cloud computing how real taxes fit into virtual clouds may 4, 2012. Tennessee now includes in the definition of a taxable use of computer software the access and use of software that remains in possession of the seller and is remotely accessed by a customer for use in this state tenn.
Cloudy with a chance of apportionment mil awthkmarilyn a. Sut18004 application of local sales and use tax to services performed outside of a taxable county. Tax considerations of cloud computing ey united states. No improved visibility for cloud computing taxation by kendall l. Sales and use tax lr 128 has been revised and reissued due to additional information provided by the taxpayer that changed some conclusions in the original version. The company in question offers cloud computing services including. Rhode island department of revenue division of taxation. Le cloud computing en est une tres belle illustration.
Sales and use tax this technical bulletin addresses the application of the new jersey sales and use tax act n. Tax considerations in cloud computing global survey report 10 global cloud computing survey results 9 taxable nexus equipment taxable nexus people transfer pricing withholding tax value added tax rulings, apas, etc. Sales tax issues for computer software and cloud computing. Regulations on tax treatment of cloud computing kpmg. Cloud computing refers to services that allow a customer to access and use the software of a service provider. Holderness is an associate at the firms new york office. Cloud computing raises important and difficult questions in state tax law, and for. Cloud computing the term cloud, as used in this white paper, appears to have its origins in network diagrams that represented the internet, or various parts of it, as schematic clouds.
In the conduct of its business, taxpayer uses cloud computing in two distinct ways. Delivery models saas software as a service applications, typically available via the browser. Cloud taxation issues and impacts overview technology companies are at the forefront of multinationals operating in a developing new global tax environment. Rhode island division of taxation page 1 of 3 rhode island department of revenue division of taxation tax change takes effect on monday, october 1 salesuse tax to apply to vendorhosted prewritten computer software software as a service providence, r. The growth of cloud computing further brings to light the inherent. The taxation of cloud computing and digital content penn law. Whether public, private, or hybrid, cloud computing is becoming an increasingly integral part of many companies business and technology strategy. Public clouds an independent cloud service provider csp offers a range of services to unrelated parties.
Risks, data classification, safeguarding of the data to determine if current cloud computing users are adequately protecting data and addressing the risks of this type of services, auditors judgmentally selected a sample of 11 out of 2 users who responded to the survey to conduct formal interviews. Many state statutes do not specifically address cloud computing and states are taking differing positions regarding the sales and use tax treatment of a cloud model. The rise of cloud computing has brought about the rise of state taxation issues. Many state statutes do not specifically address cloud computing and states are taking differing positions regarding the sales and use tax. Cloud functions are, therefore, described as services, which leads to a host of tax issues, particularly since few states tax services, and because the issue of taxing software has traditionally been fluid the taxation of cloud computing and digital content. Iafrate kranz, cpa, jd, founder and managing member of industry sales. Pub 64, utah sales tax info for computer service providers. Pdf sales tax and cloud computing in india khagesh.
What are the sales and use tax consequences of accessing taxable canned. The sales tax profession has seen similar situations in the past. November 8, 20 you request a ruling on behalf of, with offices at, as to the application of massachusetts sales and use tax to sales of certain products, generally described as cloud computing, to customers in. Thus the tax treatment of cloud computing activities requires interpreting the current tax regulations. However, for a tax administration and other public institutions, the location of their.
Cloud computing is the latest innovation to introduce considerable complexity into the state and local tax system. The ruling provides a case study on texas tax law as it pertains to these types of services. Treasury inspector general for tax administration the internal revenue service does not have a cloud strategy and did not adhere to federal policy when deploying a cloud service august 7, 2017 reference number. Given todays tumultuous business climate, it is no surprise that legisla. The new cloud computing guidance creates an opportunity to enhance tax processes and increase tax positions around these costs. Software of that type is hosted remotely and never installed on the purchasers server 22 installed on the purchasers server. Cloud computing and state sales tax uc hastings scholarship. No improved visibility for cloud computing taxation. If remotely accessed software is used at more than one location and at the time of the transaction, the buyer provides the seller a reasonable and consistent method for allocating the trans. According to your letter, the terms, cloud computing and digital content. The collaborative work enabled by cloud computing is particularly useful for a. As the nature of the cca costs incurred will dictate treatment for both tax and book purposes, the new standard can also be an opportunity to create synergies related to data gathering around such positions. Taxable based on leasing space on a server, storing data on a.
Corporate income tax economic nexus purchasers of cloud computing services. Kpmg international provides no client services and is a swiss entity with which the independent. As a result, tax administrators are stuck trying to fit a square peg in a round hole by applying yesterdays laws to todays technology. Luongo in the past year or so, there have been several articles written on the topic of cloud computing and the potential tax consequences of various types of cloud transactions. Cloud computing saas, paas, iaas tb72 issued july 3, 20 tax. Of nine states that have recently issued administrative guidance on the taxability of cloud computing services, only two have found the services taxable. Accessing taxable canned software is taxable when the user is located in pennsylvania. The sat uses cloud services since 2012, with the azure provider. The vast majority 63 percent said it was too difficult to determine when their organizations would realize the. The latest controversy regarding the taxability of software is cloud computing. An introduction to cloud computing and international trade. The paper, the first of its kind, examines the sales tax implications on cloud computing transactions in india.
The michigan department of treasury has announced that the sections of rab 19995 that suggest that access to software over the internet is taxable without the delivery of either the code that enables the program to operate or a desk top client are inconsistent with the court of appeals decision in autoowners insurance. As with all emerging technological advances, states have struggled to apply their current taxation standards to cloud computing. First, the concept of cloud computing is explained. Google apps paas platform as a service hosted application environment for building and deploying cloud applications. State taxation of cloud computing santa clara law digital. Pennsylvania department of revenue tax information tax law. The vast majority 63 percent said it was too difficult to determine when their organizations would realize the full benefits of the cloud. This is the fourth and final part of our blog series addressing issues related to the taxation of cloud based transactions. Taxable where they have a physical presence servers, infrastructure, employees, etc. Sut12001 cloud computing issue what are the sales and use tax consequences of accessing taxable canned software on remote servers, also known as cloud computing. Installing appropriate taxrisk management procedures. Unleashing the potential of cloud computing in europe. Kpmg survey on the tax implications of cloud computing, just 18 percent of tax departments among the 800 companies surveyed were maximizing the benefits of operating in the cloud.
132 1006 1313 1399 913 312 1164 1497 795 1157 351 1128 717 606 835 482 650 1347 1505 1373 107 77 1358 1373 279 620 1154 1020 830